fb-pixel
Information

What is inside and outside IR35

Avatar
Last updated July 15, 2020

There is no statutory definition of a contract of service (employment contract) and therefore we must look to the courts and their case law decisions for guidance.

The leading case on this issue is Ready Mixed Concrete (South East) Ltd v Minister of Pensions and National Insurance 1968 which laid the foundations of the tests which are used today.

Over the years, case law has developed and confirmed that in order for a contract of service to exist, the following three conditions must be satisfied:

  1. The individual is obliged to provide the services personally (personal service)
  2. The individual is subject to control by the engager as to how he provides the services (control)
  3. An obligation must exist on the engager to provide work and an obligation on the individual to undertake the work. (Mutuality of Obligations)

It follows that if any one of these criteria on the below checklist is missing, the contract cannot be a contract of service and is more indicative of a contract for services (self-employment).

Personal Service:

Is personal service missing?

  • Having an unfettered right to substitute
  • Engagement being between two limited companies/LLPs and not with an individual
  • Not referring to a specific individual throughout the contract
  • Being named personally as a party to the agreement
  • Having no right to substitute
  • Having an unfettered right to substitute
  • Client being able to request the removal of an individual for any reason
  • Personally be tied into the engagement

Control:

Is control missing?

  • Complete autonomy over how the services are carried out
  • No supervision, direction or control
  • Freedom to choose location and hours
  • Being managed
  • Client having input into how
  • Supervised, controlled or directed
  • Being closely monitored
  • Following client procedures/methodology

Mutuality of Obligation:

Is there a lack of mutual obligations?

  • No obligation to accept further work
  • No obligation to accept additional work outside the scope of agreed services
  • No obligation to see the engagement through to completion
  • Possibility of early termination
  • Obligation for agreement to be extended
  • Requirement to accept any work provided by the client
  • No possibility of early termination

These lists are not exhaustive and even if one of the points is lacking, does not automatically put you ‘inside’ or ‘outside’ IR35. Every case must be considered entirely on its merits and both the contractual and working terms must be considered.


Avatar
Last updated July 15, 2020

Related IR35 content

6 Questions you need to ask yourself about IR35

The fundamentals of IR35 are NOT changing: understanding the key status indicators – personal service, control, and mutuality of obligations – is…

Read more

The impact on contractors of the deferral of private sector IR35 reform until April 2021

Since Steve Barclay, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury announced a 12-month delay to the IR35 private sector reform in…

Read more

Why do I need an IR35 contract review?

If you are a contractor with any doubts as to the compliance and validity of your contract in relation to…

Read more

How does HMRC define a PSC?

IR35 – or the Intermediaries Legislation – was introduced by HMRC in 2000, and was aimed at individuals who were…

Read more

What is IR35 and how does it work?

IR35 – or the Intermediaries Legislation – was introduced by HMRC in 2000, and was aimed at individuals who were…

Read more

What is a contract review and do I need one?

A Contact Review is a report that independent tax specialists such as Markel Tax provide to contractors giving an opinion…

Read more

IR35 changes 2021: What you need to know

The Government has reaffirmed plans to make changes to off-payroll working (IR35) rules effective from April 2021. The main principles…

Read more

What is inside and outside IR35

There is no statutory definition of a contract of service (employment contract) and therefore we must look to the courts…

Read more

Will contractors still need insurance for IR35 after April 6th?

Amendment: On March the 18th 2020, the Government announced that the roll-out of private sector IR35 reform would be postponed…

Read more

What is IR35 and how will it affect you as a freelance contractor?

For many freelancers, IR35 sounds like another jargon term that has no relevance to them and there is a concerning…

Read more

The Right of Substitution

The right of substitution is one of the key tests of your IR35 employment status as set out by the…

Read more

Mutuality of Obligation (MOO)

Mutuality of Obligation refers to the obligation of the employer to provide work and pay for it. This is combined…

Read more

Retain your control as a contractor to keep IR35 at bay

Control is one of the three key points that is used to determine whether a contractor is working inside IR35…

Read more

Why do I need an IR35 contract review?

If you are a contractor with any doubts as to the compliance and validity of your contract in relation to…

Read more

The importance of an IR35 Contract Review for private sector contractors

If you are a private sector contractor, you should be fully aware of the private sector IR35 changes that are…

Read more

What is IR35 and how does it affect you?

This Partner Programme is offered by our partners at Caunce O’Hara Insurance Brokers Limited. To find out more please visit…

Read more

PSCs inside IR35 – Keep Calm and carry out some research

A week on since the Finance Bill 2017 became law public sector contractors who operate through PSCs are facing a…

Read more

IR35 Products & services

Caunce O’Hara’s partnership with Markel enables us to offer a broad range of IR35-based products to protect contractors, fee-payers and end clients across the UK.

IR35 Hub Related IR35 content