The blanket approach to IR35

Georgina Hiles Markel Tax
Written by Georgina Hiles
Last updated November 12, 2020

The delay in the introduction of the IR35 legislation allowed contractors and their clients extra time to prepare. It also provided the luxury of looking at decisions made by end-clients in the run up to April 2020 and use that as a guide to how the run up to April 2021 might unfold.

Engagements which were truly outside of IR35 before the change will still be outside of IR35 after the change. Or will they?

Blanket status decisions

One development we saw during the preparations for the April 2020 deadline was the use of blanket status decisions.

These were of two types: firstly, a decision to stop using IR35 contractors altogether, which is effectively a decision to remove the need to make a decision on status.

The second was a blanket view that everyone providing the same service to an end-client must be treated in the same way for IR35 purposes.

This is an attractive view to end-clients as it dramatically reduces the administrative overhead in carrying out status tests and, to be fair, in some cases it is an accurate view. However, one size fits all approaches only work if everyone is the same size!  This isn’t automatically the case with IR35 status.

There is also tension between an end-client wanting an easy status solution and a contractor wanting a personalised answer. A further issue is that it isn’t always clear what the end-client will base a decision upon.

In most cases the end-client and the contractor are separated by an agency sitting within the supply chain. This means that there are two contracts in place, one between the client and the agency (the upper contract) and one between the agency and the contractor (the lower contract).

In an ideal world both contracts would be considered in a status revie, but in reality the client and the contractor may only have sight of the contract they are party too. The detail the end-client needs is mainly within the lower contract as this details the contractor’s rights and obligations under the arrangements.

The only other information the client is party to will be the actual working practices.

In reality, the person making the status decision may not have day-to-day responsibility for the contractor or even any personal understanding of how the service is provided.

The situation becomes even more unclear where there are several contractors provided via different agencies. The key facts will differ from contractor to contractor and so, potentially, will the status.

Faced with this sort of uncertainty, and the need to ensure a robust decision making process, and the need to handle any appeals against status decisions it is unsurprising that many businesses took the decision to simply side step the entire process by ending the use of IR35 contractors.

Blanket IR35 status decision

Can blanket decision making work?

The simple answer is yes, it can. Although that simple answer isn’t much help by itself.

What end-client’s really need to know, is under what circumstances can it work and what information do they need to have access to?

Markel Tax’s view is that blanket decisions will only have any value where the contracting population can be easily segmented into groups with identical contracts and working practices.

That would probably only be the case where they are working on the same deliverables and have the same liaison point within the client project team and are contracting through the same agency.

The same liaison is a way to show that the working practices are likely to be the same across that group of contractors. If that cannot be achieved then blanket decisions are not a recommended route to follow.

The pros and cons of blanket decisions

The pros are that it will dramatically reduce the cost of reviewing subcontractor’s status after the private sector IR35 rules go live. This will be by virtue of the reduction in individual reviews carried out.

Set against this is the view taken by many that an even bigger reduction could be achieved by simply not using IR35 contractors at all. That latter option will be driven by the likelihood that existing contractors would agree to operate through other, personally less beneficial, engagement models such as umbrella company employment.

The downsides to blanket decisions are many.

Each contractor still has an individual right of appeal and may well appeal on the grounds that the decision is not personalised to their exact arrangements.

The profile of the contracting workforce may not allow the kind of segmentation that would support a blanket approach. If there are lots of individual projects each with different contracts, deliverables, skill profiles and project managers then creating groups to be reviewed as a single process is almost impossible.

Last but not least, is the fact that HMRC expect reasonable care to be taken in the status decision and have specifically warned against blanket decisions under threat of debt transfer and penalties.

Click here to read our article on IR35 Debt Transfers

Alternatives to blanket decisions

Perhaps the question shouldn’t be ‘can we use a blanket decision system?’, but ‘what are we trying to achieve by using them?’ That allows different strategies to be considered that may lead to the same benefits.

One option would be to outsource the review process. Nothing within the new legislation says that the end-client must personally carry out the review. This allows the option of using a third-party provider rather like outsourcing payroll functions.

However, the end-client is still responsible for the accuracy of the review and liable for any penalties arising due to errors. Having an expert and independent third party carry out testing minimises these risks and some may provide an insurance solution.

Under the current rules many contractors have their working arrangements reviewed for IR35 compliance and this option would be a variation on that service. It has the added benefit of having a number of existing providers with a good record in this area.

Another option might be to require the agency to do the review. They have sight of both the upper and lower contract and can check the working practices with both the contractor and the client.

To some extent they are in the perfect position within the supply chain to do this. Again, they could outsource the actual review and could seek to insure the decision. The agency as the fee payer would benefit but ultimately the end-client would have to sign off and take responsibility for the accuracy of the review process.

Having the contractor carry out a review may appear as an attractive third option but it flies in the face of the objectives of the legislation which is to separate the party making the check from the party who benefits from that decision.

We consider that HMRC would take a very close look at any such arrangements and would probably consider them as being in breach of the legislation, unless very stringent cross checks were put in place, which would defeat the original objective.

For further information, please email Georgina Hiles or contact Markel Tax on 0333 920 5708.


You can read up-to-date news about IR35 here

Georgina Hiles Markel Tax
Written by Georgina Hiles
Last updated November 12, 2020

Related IR35 content

HMRC launches consultation into IR35 ‘double taxation’

HMRC has confirmed that it has launched an 8-week consultation on plans to roll out a legislative tweak that could…

Read more

Heigh-ho, heigh-ho, it’s back to Chapter 10 we go!

The vast majority of limited company contractors would have gone to work with a spring in their step when they…

Read more

Plans to repeal IR35 scrapped by new Chancellor

It’s been an eventful few weeks in UK politics and for the UK economy. With the pound struggling against the…

Read more

Off-payroll working legislation IR35 reforms to be repealed from April 2023

On Friday 23 September 2022, as part of his mini-budget speech, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Kwasi Kwarteng, committed to…

Read more

More tax avoidance schemes identified by HMRC

At the end of August 2022, it came to light that HMRC had identified three more tax avoidance schemes as…

Read more

Will the new prime minister amend IR35?

On 5 September 2022, Liz Truss was elected – with 57.4% of the vote – as the new prime minister…

Read more

Top TV stars to pay more tax and potentially lose some freedom in contract crackdown

Broadcaster set to force their top TV stars to work PAYE In a recent story published by The Sun1, it…

Read more

IR35: Private sector firms warned of potentially large HMRC penalties on the horizon

HMRC confirmed it would take a “light touch” in regards to enforcing the new IR35 rules for the initial 12…

Read more

IR35 one year on. 60% of contractors report drop in income.

The results are in! Firstly, we’d like to say thank you to everyone who got involved in our IR35 survey,…

Read more

Contractors could be entitled to reclaim tax if IR35 is misapplied

In recent articles by and, it has come to light that HMRC has acknowledged that contractors could be…

Read more

Investigation into the IR35 reforms launched by the National Audit Office (NAO)

A recent report by the National Audit Office (NAO) has stated that Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC) faces new…

Read more

Seven year nightmare over for presenter Adrian Chiles as Basic Broadcasting Limited wins IR35 appeal

A positive IR35 case ruling has been made for presenter Adrian Chiles and his media company Basic Broadcasting Limited, after…

Read more

Umbrella consultation underway

Umbrella company consultation The government has launched a consultation into the role that umbrella companies play in the labour market…

Read more

Former SKY Sports presenter landing with heavy IR35 tax bill

Former SKY Sports presenter loses IR35 tribunal appeal Former SKY Sports presenter Dave Clark has lost his IR35 tribunal appeal…

Read more

Blanket contractor IR35 decisions U-turn by Network Rail recently reported that Network Rail appears to have performed a U-turn of its IR35 blanket decisions for the rail…

Read more

HM Courts & Tribunal Service becomes the third government department to be hit with IR35 tax bill

Government departments have been in the news recently for their incorrect assessments of the employment status of their contractors in…

Read more

Home Office hit with huge IR35 tax bill

It has recently emerged that the Home Office has been hit with a £33.5 million IR35 tax bill after a…

Read more

DWP hit with huge tax bill for historic IR35 contractor status assessment errors

It has emerged that the Department for Work & Pensions (DWP) was hit with a huge £87.9 million tax bill…

Read more

IR35 private sector changes to go ahead next week

Changes to IR35 in the private sector will go ahead on 6th April 2021, despite hopes for a further delay….

Read more

Kaye Adams wins case and is ruled outside IR35 due to being ‘in business on own account’

A case that will be welcomed by PSCs In a landmark IR35 case that will be welcomed by PSCs, but…

Read more

UK Supreme Court rules that Uber drivers are workers not self-employed

Thousands of Uber drivers could be entitled to minimum wage The Supreme Court’s unanimous decision should come as no surprise…

Read more

Private sector IR35 soon to be reality

On April 6th 2021, the contractor’s worst scenario will become reality… IR35 in the private sector will finally go live….

Read more

Just 2 months left until the IR35 reform: what do contractors need to know?

On the 6th April 2021, the IR35 private sector changes will come into effect. With this date now just a…

Read more

The blanket approach to IR35

The delay in the introduction of the IR35 legislation allowed contractors and their clients extra time to prepare. It also…

Read more

IR35 news: Eamonn Holmes loses his IR35 case against HMRC

Holmes, a broadcaster for over 40 years, was providing his services through a limited company called Red, White and Green…

Read more

HMRC “kicks back” in latest IR35 case

HMRC “kicks back” at Upper Tribunal in latest win against Paul Hawksbee In July 2019 we saw the fight between…

Read more

Off-payroll working in the private sector

IR35 is coming Despite the protests and lobbying of the Government, the only reference in the Budget notes makes it…

Read more

The impact of finance sector IR35 decisions on contractors

IR35 reform to the private sector was already having a negative impact on contractors working in the finance sector prior…

Read more

Lord’s committee expresses concerns over IR35

IR35 off-payroll reform was due to be rolled-out to the private sector on April 6th of this year, but due…

Read more

Suggestions to move IR35 reforms to 2023 are rejected

Amendments to the IR35 private sector are set to go ahead from April 2021, despite suggestions from a Conservative MP…

Read more

COVID-19 and IR35: Should your clients relax now the legislation is postponed?

Changes to off-payroll working in the private sector delayed 12 months Steve Barclay, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, announced…

Read more

11th hour delay for IR35 private sector reform due to COVID-19 welcomed

The Government has delayed its controversial IR35 private sector reform by one year, until April 2021, because of the COVID-19…

Read more

No delay to IR35 rollout as the Government launches off-payroll review

The Government launched its off-payroll review on January 7th with regards to the implementation of the changes to the off-payroll…

Read more

What are the political parties saying about IR35?

The changes that will alter how freelancers’ taxes are assessed In April 2020 the contractor and freelance community are set…

Read more

Six reasons for PSCs to be proactive to respond to the IR35 private sector changes and not wait until April 2020 to do so!

Since April 2000, the Intermediaries legislation has made the individual contractor trading through his/her own Personal Service Company (PSC) the…

Read more

What impact will IR35 reforms have on North Sea operators?

With high levels of talent engaged through off payroll structures in the energy sector, the North Sea operators will feel…

Read more

Are you ready for IR35 changes?

Proposed changes to IR35 legislation could mean thousands of contractors may pay more tax. With the Government’s consultation on contracting…

Read more

IR35 and CEST Update

The IR35 story continues to rumble on taking twists and turns along the way and most of us believe it…

Read more

U-Turn on Self-employed NIC but no change to Public Sector rules on IR35

The ink has yet to dry on Philip Hammond’s first budget as Chancellor but his proposed national insurance increases for…

Read more

IR35 Products & services

Caunce O’Hara’s partnership with Markel enables us to offer a broad range of IR35-based products to protect contractors, fee-payers and end clients across the UK.

IR35 Hub Related IR35 content